);

Sinterklaas in the Netherlands: Tradition, Change and the Ongoing Debate

Confused about Sinterklaas in the Netherlands? Learn the history, meaning and modern reality of this Dutch tradition in a clear and factual way.
Dec 1

Sinterklaas in the Netherlands

If you are new to the Netherlands, chances are you have heard about Sinterklaas. Often not through the celebration itself, but through public debate. Discussions about tradition, change and identity can sound intense, especially when viewed from the outside.


To really understand Sinterklaas, it helps to separate three things:

the children’s celebration, the historical background, and the public discussion around it.

What Sinterklaas actually is

Sinterklaas is a traditional children’s celebration held on the evening of 5 December. It is centered around Saint Nicholas, a historical figure known for generosity and care for children.


For most Dutch families, Sinterklaas is calm, playful and strongly focused on children. It is not a religious event in daily life, but a cultural one.

Children’s traditions you will see everywhere


Putting a shoe by the door

In the weeks before 5 December, children put their shoe by the fireplace or door. They often add a drawing or a carrot for the horse. During the night, Sinterklaas or his helpers leave a small gift or sweets in the shoe.

This tradition is very common in families, schools and childcare centers.


Songs and stories

Children sing Sinterklaas songs, often about kindness, listening well and helping others. These songs are learned at school and daycare and are part of the shared cultural experience.


Presents and poems

On 5 December, gifts are exchanged. For older children and adults, gifts are often accompanied by humorous poems. These poems tease gently and play with daily habits or personality traits.


Chocolate letters

One of the most visible traditions is the chocolate letter. The letter usually represents the first letter of a person’s name and is sold everywhere in November and December.


The story of Spain

Traditionally, Sinterklaas arrives from Spain by boat. In older stories, naughty children were told that Sinterklaas might take them back to Spain. Today this element is mostly symbolic and playful, and many parents avoid using it seriously.

The public debate around Sinterklaas is mainly about how traditions evolve in a diverse society. Sociologists describe this as a cultural renegotiation process. Traditions are not fixed. They change when societies change.

The Netherlands has a long history of discussing traditions openly. This is part of a broader cultural pattern where disagreement is seen as normal and even healthy. Open debate does not automatically mean rejection of people or cultures. It is often a way of negotiating shared values.


Research from Dutch cultural institutes shows that many Dutch people are able to hold two ideas at the same time:

they can enjoy a tradition emotionally, while also accepting that parts of it may change over time.

The role of helpers and the Zwarte Piet discussion

Historically, Sinterklaas was accompanied by helpers known as Zwarte Piet. These characters were portrayed with blackface, colorful clothing and exaggerated features.


Over time, especially from the 2010s onward, this portrayal became the subject of intense public debate. Critics pointed out the racist origins and harmful stereotypes connected to blackface. Supporters initially saw it as an innocent children’s tradition without racist intent.


This debate is not about children’s joy, but about representation and historical context. Research in social psychology and cultural studies shows that symbols can have different meanings depending on lived experience. What feels neutral to one group can feel painful to another.


As a result, many cities, schools and broadcasters changed the appearance of the helpers. Today you will mostly see helpers with soot marks on their faces, often explained as marks from climbing through chimneys.


This change happened gradually and differently across regions. It reflects how Dutch society often deals with tradition: through discussion, disagreement and slow adaptation.

Why the debate can sound intense

Dutch culture places a strong value on open debate. Disagreement is not automatically seen as conflict or rejection of others. It is a normal way to negotiate social change.


This can feel confronting for internationals, especially those from cultures where public disagreement is avoided. In the Netherlands, discussing tradition openly is often seen as a sign that society takes it seriously.

Importantly, most Dutch people separate the debate from the celebration itself. In daily life, Sinterklaas celebrations are usually calm, inclusive and focused on children having fun.

What internationals usually experience in practice

If you have children, you will likely encounter Sinterklaas through school or daycare. Schools usually explain the celebration clearly and follow modern guidelines around inclusivity.


If you do not have children, you might notice decorations, chocolate letters and public events, but little direct involvement.


In both cases, you are not expected to have a strong opinion or take a position. Curiosity and respect are enough. Asking questions is generally welcomed.

Why understanding this matters

Sinterklaas is a good example of how Dutch culture works more broadly. Traditions exist. They matter. At the same time, they are not fixed. They change through discussion and social awareness.


Understanding this helps internationals interpret other cultural debates in the Netherlands as well. Directness, public discussion and gradual change are recurring patterns.

Learning Dutch also means learning how culture, language and debate interact. At Dutch Online, we help you understand not only the words, but also the context behind them.

FAQ: Sinterklaas

Looking for more tips? Check out our other articles!